Friday, December 5, 2008
either/or, both/and
as time goes on, i tend to see the content of the bible as more descriptive than prescriptive. hence, i propose that the christian assembly and its practices portrayed in the NT did not follow a purpose prescribed from an outside source. conformity to a set of rules or expectations for an assembly was absent, save that of the church's jewish roots and later gentile influence. the markers of an assembly were determined by past experience and by the urgent needs of the christian community led by the spirit. worship or edification? both occur. if i think of that choice in terms of function, edification wins by two lengths. (duplicated from my comment on the first post)
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

5 comments:
I agree with the descriptive/prescriptive remark ... except that some biblical teaching is clearly intended to be prescriptive. Our common mistake is taking all the other descriptive language and making it prescriptive.
I really like your other comment (i.e., that "the NT did not follow a purpose prescribed from an outside source"). I've been discussing this issue for 30+ years, and no one has stated this comment to me. I've thought of this general concept many times, but I've never verbalized it.
Yet, there is a (prescriptive) biblical statement that works against this concept: 1 Cor. 14:26 and the whole of that chapter. Paul, in an attempt to regulate assembly activities and prevent abuses, lays down the (prescriptive) principle that "all things must be done for edification."
Concerning the both/and proposition ... I agree, but only if we accept the modern definition of "worship" as "praise." After all, praising God certainly occurs in the assembly.
However, none of the Greek terms that are translated as "worship" can be defined as "praise." Herein lies the great semantic "worship" conundrum. After spending years studying the Greek terms that are commonly translated as "worship," I have concluded that "worship" is an inadequate and misleading translation.
I have come to believe that the early Christians would be appalled to hear us say that the purpose of 'church' is "worship" (particularly if we are using proskuneo or latreuo as the Greek word for "worship").
I'll stop there and wait for a response.
(Note: If you posted a previous comment, I didn't see it. I hope I've set up this blog correctly.)
"on this rock i will build my church" did not imply two songs and a prayer before communion.
where does one draw the line between 'prescriptive' and 'descriptive'? for all we know, paul meant those veil instructions to be observed for all time.
it is hard to separate my struggles with prayer from this thread. what if the scope of 'ask and you will receive' is much more limited (to their time) than we think?
I think it's difficult to "draw the line between prescriptive and descriptive." For that reason, we all need to be more forgiving and less judgmental of those who interpret scriptures differently.
You appropriately cited Paul's veil instructions. I remember struggling with that issue when we were at HGSR together, and I still struggle with it. The "it's cultural" argument is simply a Big Guess.
But I'd like to bring us back to the worship/edification issue. I don't mean to imply that all who take a different view are going to hell. But I strongly believe that the two views lead to two very different kinds of Christianity.
The Worship view, while having the appearance of being God-honoring orthodoxy, actually leads to a stagnant religion that gets caught up in fighting over frivolous details.
The Edification view, on the other hand, leads to a vibrant religion that focuses on love and compassion, as well as corporate and individual growth and maturity.
To my knowledge, modern Christianity has very little experience with the Edification view.
Comments?
i think worship becomes the form that functions as a substitute for real activity. edification does seem more attractive, and most folks respond to it better. but edif. can just as easily become a substitute for actually doing something. i belong to a church group for the human contact, though i still value some ritual. if i did not have other distractions or family obligations, it would not hold my interest. i will give it more thought and maybe add more later.
You may be right that "edification can just as easily become a substitute for actually doing something." Yet, in my mind, edification--by definition--IS actually doing something of substantive benefit.
You say you "still value some ritual." I think millions of modern Christians have been trained by hundreds of years of ritual to find some value in it.
Ultimately, though, I think it's a hollow activity that has more in common with superstition than with genuine Christianity.
If I were pressed to find some biblical basis for Christian ritual, I would point to 1 Cor. 11 and the Lord's Supper (as well as the gospel accounts of the supper). Yet, Jesus instituted the supper to be rich with meaning. Consequently, it is a valid source of edification.
But, outside of the supper, there is little evidence of Christian ritual.
Some scholars see evidence of liturgy in the New Testament documents. (Liturgy is a form of ritual.) Yet, I think these scholars are often reading liturgy back into the text.
[I appreciate you participating in this discussion. I've been writing a book on this topic for the last 8 years, and this discussion helps me sharpen my thoughts.]
Post a Comment